1957 Greenwich Village: Barney Rosset, Evergreen Press and The Cedar Tavern


Reobert Frank's The Americans was published by Grove Press in 1959
Reobert Frank’s The Americans was published by Grove Press in 1959

Two films recently got me thinking about Barney Rosset, the firebrand publisher of Grove Press and Evergreen Review. First, An American Journey: Revisiting Robert Frank’s The Americans by Philippe Séclier. I was not enamored of the film, which did not, in my opinion, do justice to Frank‘s photographic genius or the seminal book that forms the centerpiece of the film. However, the film did remind me of the struggle Frank had to get the work published in the United States, and the role Barney Rosset played in publishing the monograph of 83 black and white photographs, which is widely considered pivotal in the history of photography. The second film, New York in the 50’s, based on a book of the same name by Dan Wakefield, was great fun to watch, mostly because it brought me back to the heady days of the late 50’s in Greenwich Village.

Cedar Tavern, 1959, © John Cohen/Getty Images
Cedar Tavern, 1959, © John Cohen/Getty Images

I first met Barney Rosset at the Cedar Tavern, then at University Place at 8th St. It was the primary watering hole for Jackson Pollock, Willem de Kooning, and other Abstract Expressionists. The conversation there often centered around “Is it art?”, a question that has also shadowed photography. (See my recent interview with Ted Forbes, The Art of Photography host, on this same question). The Beat writers of the day were also in attendance. Kerouac and Ginsberg and latter Bob Dylan. Alcohol flowed relentlessly releasing inhibitions and sometimes ruining the very genius it helped unleash. Pollock would eventually be banned from the Cedar for tearing the doors off the men’s room. In his film, Dan Wakefield shares his own story of a night of drunkeness, which led to a botched attempt to slit his wrists due to a romantic rift. The next morning he was being interviewed for a Neiman Fellowship, which he somehow managed to get! I hate admitting how much I participated in this manic ritual, but I’m happy to say that those days are well behind me and now I kneel at the altar of AA.

1957 was a big year for me. I was 26 years old, and preparing for my first child. I had finished a show at Helen Gee’s Limelight Gallery and surrendered my space at the Jazz Loft to W. Eugene Smith. I moved into another loft at 747 Sixth Avenue with a bit more space. My partner at the time, Dorrie Woodson, was a jazz pianist and we were just scraping by (which I did most of my early life). I had begun teaching and, unbeknownst to me at the time, I was about to receive a teaching fellowship at The Annenberg School of Communications, which would take me out of New York and down to Philadelphia for a number of years.

Enter Barney Rosset who offered me the opportunity to help launch the premiere issue of Evergreen Review, which would become America’s most avant-garde and controversial literary journal. I can’t remember what he paid me for the cover photo and the eight page spread, but whatever it was, I needed it. I had earned some money as a designer for Blue Note Records and offered my design services for the issue also, for which he probably paid me a bit more.


The first issue featured a story by Samuel Beckett and an essay by Jean-Paul Sartre. Rosset would become Beckett’s most ardent promoter in the United States having published Waiting for Godot in 1954 after everyone else had refused it. The second issue of Evergreen brought the Beat writers front and center in one forum for the first time.

The New York Times described Rosset as:

the flamboyant, provocative publisher who helped change the course of publishing in the United States, bringing masters like Samuel Beckett to Americans’ attention under his Grove Press imprint and winning celebrated First Amendment slugfests against censorship,

In the 1960s Rosset defied censors by publishing D. H. Lawrence’s Lady Chatterley’s Lover and Henry Miller’s Tropic of Cancer, winning legal battles that opened the door to sexually provocative language and subject matter in literature published in the United States.

In addition to being the primary champion of writers like Samuel Beckett, Pablo Neruda, Jack Kerouac, Henry Miller, Octavia Paz, Harold Pinter and many others, he also provided a platform for Che Guevera, Ho Chi Minh, Malcolm X, Frantz Fanon and other heroes of the Left. In 1968, his office was bombed by a hand grenade by anti-Castro advocates for publishing Che Guevera’s, The Bolivian Diary. No one was hurt.

Samuel Beckett and Barney Ross, 1968 © Bob Adelman
Samuel Beckett and Barney Ross, 1968 © Bob Adelman

In the 70’s the ferment he had helped to cultivate came back to bite him. When employees tried to unionize he called the police. The union proposal was defeated. After the union vote failed, he fired half his workers. He was accused by feminists of sexism and misogyny in some of his publications. Later, under financial stress, he sold Grove Press to the oil heiress, Anne Getty but kept Evergreen Review going online. His contributions were great. His flaws were also…just like the rest of us! He died in 2012.

Thinking back on Rosset, I associate him with my memories of New York in the late 50’s. It’s tempting to think of those times as “the good old days”, and to be sure there was an intoxicating romance to the creativity and daring that characterized the time. It was liberating to a point, but in hindsight it was limited by its own shadows. I suppose that’s a perennial lesson of history. In his New York Times op-ed Bye Bye Bohemia about the final closing of The Cedar Tavern, cultural critic Lee Siegel, painted a picture of the famed watering hole as a place at once heady, but also hedonistic, and not friendly to women or gay — a fact too true then and now. I found his conclusion interesting, though perhaps a bit too sweeping.

Enlightened social attitudes and revolutionary artistic creation rarely go hand in hand.

I’m sure there are too many exceptions to that statement. But, there’s always room for reflection, and whether that’s true or not, I’ll keep some faith that the two are getting closer and closer together.


  1. Ruth Thompson

    What an amazing and revelatory piece of cultural history. I’d love to know which photos went into the original edition of Evergreen. Loved reading this!!!

    • Harold Feinstein

      Thanks Ruth! I actually meant to include some of the photos from that issue and forgot to do that! A few of them haven’t been seen much since and others are classics! Will send them along for you to see and perhaps do an up-date on this blog at some point!

  2. Jennifer (Thompson) Oberhauser

    A great read, Harold. So lovely to hear your voice. I hadn’t quite realized you were such a painter with WORDS as well, not that I’m terribly surprised. Much love!
    Always your student, ~Jennifer

  3. Keith Green

    Although a bit before my time, I’m fascinated with this era of art in New York City. I read Dan Wakefield’s New York in the 1950s, and in past years, I would frequent the Cedar Tavern when it was relocated to 11th Street and University Place. After reading a feature in New York Magazine a few years ago which profiled Eugene Smith and his photographs captured at the Jazz Loft, the article’s writer actually listed the address of that infamous loft. It was then I realized that I once lived in that very same building on 6th Ave. in the loft on the floor directly below. This was during the late 1980s and in studying the photographs taken by Eugene at that time, I recalled that the layout and details of the loft had not changed even when I was living there. I wish I had known at the time of the historical significance.

    • Harold Feinstein

      821 Sixth Avenue was indeed a hotspot in the 50’s. I was one of the original inhabitants until I turned it over to Gene. I hadn’t realized that address was still around in the 80’s. Was a fun time!

  4. Vincent Cianni

    Harold, this was one of the most engaging,informative AND entertaining pieces I’ve read in some time. Your recall of events and writing are wonderful. Especially liked the line “Alcohol flowed relentlessly releasing inhibitions and sometimes ruining the very genius it helped unleash.” Thanks for a good read.

    • Harold Feinstein

      Glad you enjoyed it Vince. As for the alcohol flowing…it’s surprising I remember much at all about my time at The Cedar! Best regards to you

  5. Norman H Gershman


    I only wish I could afford going back and living in the Village and just walking the streets. I recall so well your place on Jane Street and think of you whenever I am in the city and near the Village. I think of you a lot, just you and your kindness. With your old cranking computer machine giving me the encouragement to move on and to keep moving, to throw away the fantasies of defeat. My work continues. Lots of exhibitions, a book, writings and now a full length film of the work I am doing. It would be fun to see you again. I am in NY a lot and sometime in April there will be an event in NY for me sponcerd by the Albanian government.

    In Aspen I knew the woman whom you photographed long ago of her squirting milk from her breast!

    Keep writing Harold as it warms me with our love of photography and the wonderful life you live.


    • Harold Feinstein

      My dear Norman: The times we had seem like yesterday. Life has a way of being true to who we really are and mine is no exception. As I listen to things I said way back then, they still hold true to me now. Except, I am a happier man now than I was then. I send you many warm thoughts. I’m so happy for your deserved successes on your project. Judith has been interested in what you’ve been doing for a long time. I hope you get to meet her also at some point!

  6. Allan MacGregor

    Hi Harold,
    This wonderful blog is chock full of memories for me, too. I lived at 42 Charles Street in the Village for a year, beginning in 1958. Oh, how I wish I had known you then! I had a very close aunt and uncle who lived at 28 Greenwich Ave. for over 40 years, so the Village played a large role in my life for many years. Their apartment looked out on Patchen Place and eecumings apartment. I think Judith said she lived there for a while. Thanks so much for fanning some of the embers back into flames – albeit somewhat diminished by age & a flagging memory. Looking forward to seeing you and Judith in April!
    Hugs from Mexico,
    Allan (& Barbara)

    • Harold Feinstein

      Maybe we can wind back the clock and meet up at the Cedar! Can’t wait to see you!

      • Allan MacGregor

        I wish we could meet at the Cedar Tavern! I also wish I had saved my copies of the Evergreen Review! Barney Rosset was a giant of publishing and civil liberties. Allan